Why the Volvo XC90 Beats the BMW X5 for 2024: A Comprehensive Comparison

When you're in the market for a premium luxury SUV two names tend to stand out—the Volvo XC90 and the BMW X5. Both vehicles have built their reputations on comfort advanced tech and premium design but when you're deciding between the two which one should you choose? This is where the Volvo XC90 pulls ahead especially for 2024.

While the BMW X5 is definitely a strong contender with its sporty performance and elegant interior the XC90 has some surprising advantages that make it a better all-around package for many drivers.

Let's dive deep into the comparison between these two powerhouse SUVs and break down how each one stacks up against the other. We'll touch on everything from performance and interior features to safety and even potential drawbacks.

Performance: Power Meets Efficiency

When it comes to performance both the Volvo XC90 and the BMW X5 bring their A-game to the table but the focus of each vehicle diverges significantly.

Volvo XC90: A Balanced Powertrain

The Volvo XC90 offers a range of powertrain options including a plug-in hybrid. The Recharge T8 AWD variant provides a compelling blend of power and efficiency boasting a combined 455 horsepower from its electric and gas engines. The fact that it's a plug-in hybrid means you can enjoy a pure electric range of around 35 miles which is a great perk for those looking to reduce their carbon footprint without sacrificing power.

While it’s not the sportiest SUV in the world it makes up for that with refinement. The ride quality is incredibly smooth and thanks to Volvo's legendary focus on safety you feel incredibly secure even at high speeds. The all-wheel-drive system performs well in all conditions giving you added confidence on slippery roads.

Potential Drawback: If you're looking for more exhilarating performance the XC90 might feel a bit more restrained compared to the X5. It’s more about balance than excitement.

BMW X5: The Performance King

The BMW X5 is undoubtedly more performance-focused. Whether you opt for the base sDrive40i or the fire-breathing M50i with its V8 engine delivering 523 horsepower the X5 is all about sporty performance. Its rear-wheel-drive bias gives it a more athletic feel and BMW's precision handling shines in every corner.

This is an SUV that feels like it wants to play. Acceleration is blistering and the handling is crisp especially for a vehicle of its size. You can even get a plug-in hybrid version (the xDrive45e) that adds an electric range of about 30 miles.

Potential Drawback: The trade-off for all this sportiness is that the BMW X5's ride can be stiffer especially on uneven roads. It’s not as cushy or smooth as the XC90 and fuel efficiency can be on the lower side especially for the more powerful models.

Interior & Comfort: Where Luxury Lives

Both the XC90 and X5 offer beautifully designed interiors but the experience inside each car is distinct.

Volvo XC90: Scandinavian Simplicity & Space

The Volvo XC90's cabin is a masterclass in minimalist Scandinavian design. It’s all about clean lines high-quality materials and a sense of calm. The interior feels like it was designed with simplicity and relaxation in mind—perfect for long trips or stressful commutes.

One of the standout features of the XC90 is its standard third-row seating. While it’s not the largest third row in the segment it’s still incredibly useful for families or those who need the extra space for passengers. The second row can slide and recline giving rear passengers plenty of comfort.

Volvo has also gone all-in on sustainability using a mix of leather-free upholstery options and eco-friendly materials. The infotainment system is powered by Google and features built-in Google Assistant and Google Maps. It's intuitive though it might take some getting used to.

Potential Drawback: Some users have noted that Volvo’s infotainment system can be laggy at times especially compared to BMW’s iDrive. The third row while useful is also best suited for kids as it can feel cramped for adults.

BMW X5: High-Tech Luxury

On the other hand the BMW X5 is all about tech and premium feel. The X5's interior feels more like a high-tech cockpit than a lounge. BMW’s iDrive 8 infotainment system is among the best in the business offering smooth and responsive navigation with a sharp display. The layout of the controls is driver-focused making you feel more connected to the car.

One area where the X5 really stands out is seating comfort. The front seats in particular offer a wide range of adjustments and come with heating cooling and massage functions. The second-row seating is also spacious but the X5's third row is optional and quite cramped—something to keep in mind if you're considering it for family use.

Potential Drawback: The amount of technology in the X5 can be overwhelming for some and while the infotainment system is excellent there’s a bit of a learning curve. The third row is also best avoided unless absolutely necessary as it feels very tight.

Safety: Volvo's Dominance vs BMW's Competence

Volvo XC90: The Benchmark for Safety

It’s no secret that Volvo has built its entire reputation on safety and the XC90 is no exception. This SUV is packed with advanced safety features that are either standard or available across all trim levels. These include:

• Pilot Assist semi-autonomous driving
• Blind Spot Monitoring with steer assist
• Rear Collision Warning
• Cross Traffic Alert with automatic braking

In terms of crash safety the Volvo XC90 scores near-perfect across the board. Volvo also offers a system that can detect large animals cyclists and pedestrians helping you avoid accidents before they happen.

Alex Collantes an automotive safety expert says “Volvo’s always been the leader in safety innovation and the XC90 carries that tradition forward—if safety is your top concern this should be your top choice.”

Potential Drawback: Despite its strong suite of safety features some drivers have mentioned that Pilot Assist can feel too intrusive and the number of safety alerts can be overwhelming in city traffic.

BMW X5: Strong but Not Class-Leading

The BMW X5 is no slouch when it comes to safety either. It offers an impressive array of standard safety features like:

• Lane Departure Warning
• Automatic Emergency Braking
• Adaptive Cruise Control

However in comparison to the Volvo it doesn’t quite match the same level of innovation. It’s plenty safe but it doesn't offer the same number of cutting-edge features as the XC90.

Potential Drawback: Some safety features in the X5 come only in higher trims or as part of additional packages which can make the car feel more expensive for safety-conscious buyers.

Technology & Infotainment: Two Different Worlds

Volvo XC90: Simplified and Google-Powered

Volvo took a unique approach by teaming up with Google for its infotainment system. With Google Assistant and Google Maps built in you get a seamless experience especially if you're already using Google services. The interface is clean but it does feel less feature-rich compared to BMW's.

One neat trick the XC90 has is the ability to receive over-the-air software updates keeping your tech fresh without needing a trip to the dealership.

Potential Drawback: As mentioned before the system isn’t the fastest and can lag during certain operations. It also lacks some of the more advanced connectivity options that the X5 offers.

BMW X5: Cutting-Edge Tech

The BMW X5 stands as one of the most technologically advanced SUVs in its class. BMW’s iDrive 8 is simply one of the best systems available. It’s intuitive responsive and incredibly well integrated with the vehicle’s controls. You also get more physical buttons compared to the Volvo which some people still prefer.

The digital dashboard in the X5 is crisp and customizable allowing you to adjust the layout to suit your needs. Apple CarPlay and Android Auto are standard but the standout feature is BMW’s Gesture Control—a futuristic way to control the infotainment system without touching anything.

Potential Drawback: As high-tech as the X5 is the Gesture Control can be finicky and some drivers find it unnecessary. Also BMW's subscription model for certain features (like heated seats) has been a controversial point.

Price & Value

Both of these luxury SUVs start at similar base prices but they diverge quickly as you move up in trim levels and options.

• Volvo XC90: Starting at around $57,000 the XC90 offers a lot of value for your money especially when you consider the amount of standard safety equipment and the fact that third-row seating is included.
• BMW X5: The X5 starts slightly higher at about $62,000 but the price can skyrocket quickly as you add options. If you want features like a third-row seat or more advanced safety systems be prepared to spend more.

Alex Collantes puts it this way “The XC90 is just a better value proposition. BMW gives you a lot of premium feel but you'll pay more for it and end up with a stiffer ride and less interior space.”

Conclusion: Which One Should You Buy?

When comparing the Volvo XC90 and the BMW X5 it really comes down to what you're looking for in a luxury SUV.

• Choose the Volvo XC90 if you prioritize safety comfort and eco-friendliness. It’s an excellent all-rounder with plenty of space and cutting-edge safety features. Plus the plug-in hybrid option is a real winner for those looking to make their drives more sustainable.

• Choose the BMW X5 if you want sportier performance and more tech-forward features. It’s a blast to drive and has more premium touches in its interior though you’ll pay for the privilege.

In the end both of these SUVs are excellent choices but the XC90 edges out the X5 in value comfort and safety which are arguably the most important factors for most buyers.