The Ultimate Comparison: Tesla Model S vs BMW X5 (2024) - Which One is Right for You?

When you’re looking for a top-tier luxury car, it’s hard to go wrong with either the Tesla Model S or the BMW X5. Both vehicles offer a premium driving experience, cutting-edge technology, and impressive performance. But which one suits your needs better? In this comparison, we’ll dive deep into every aspect of these two automotive giants so you can make the best decision. Let’s break down how they compare and what sets them apart—because while both are excellent in their own right, they’re quite different beasts under the hood.

Tesla Model S vs BMW X5 Overview

The Tesla Model S is an electric powerhouse with sleek sedan styling and futuristic technology. Known for its incredible range and acceleration, it's been a game-changer in the electric vehicle (EV) market.

The BMW X5 is a luxury SUV with versatility, blending power, comfort, and a long-standing reputation for driving excellence. It’s a great choice for those who want a traditional gas-powered vehicle, though a plug-in hybrid option is also available.

Key Differences in a Nutshell

• Tesla Model S: All-electric, 405-520 miles of range, 0-60 mph in under 2 seconds (Plaid version).
• BMW X5: Traditional gas/diesel engines plus a plug-in hybrid, up to 400 horsepower, a more spacious SUV body.

Let’s get into the nitty-gritty and explore how these two high-end vehicles measure up.

Performance and Powertrain

When comparing the Tesla Model S and the BMW X5, performance and powertrain are where these cars show their most significant differences.

Tesla Model S

The Tesla Model S is all-electric, with no internal combustion engine. Depending on the version you choose, its performance can vary. The base model offers a solid balance of range and speed, while the Model S Plaid takes things to an entirely different level with its 1,020 horsepower.

• Acceleration: The Model S can go from 0-60 mph in just 1.99 seconds with the Plaid model, making it one of the fastest cars in production.
• Range: Up to 405-520 miles on a single charge depending on the model, which is exceptional for any EV.

But it’s not all perfect. Some drivers have reported that while the acceleration is amazing, the power delivery feels almost too smooth for such a high-performance vehicle. The lack of engine noise also takes some getting used to if you're a fan of hearing that roar.

BMW X5

The BMW X5 has a wide range of engine options. The entry-level models come with a 3.0-liter inline-six engine, producing 335 horsepower. At the top end, you can opt for the X5 M version, which churns out a whopping 617 horsepower from a twin-turbocharged 4.4-liter V8 engine.

• Acceleration: With the V8, the X5 can reach 0-60 mph in about 3.8 seconds. It’s not as fast as the Model S but still very respectable, especially for an SUV.
• Hybrid Option: For those looking for better fuel efficiency, the plug-in hybrid xDrive45e model offers up to 30 miles of electric-only range before switching to gas power.

The X5’s more traditional engine options provide better sound feedback and a more familiar driving experience for those who aren’t yet ready to go all-in on electric. "I love the sound of the V8 engine in the X5 M—it gives you that visceral feeling you just don't get in an electric car," says Alex Collantes, a luxury car enthusiast who’s driven both vehicles.

Drawbacks: While the BMW X5 delivers powerful performance, it doesn’t offer the same jaw-dropping acceleration as the Tesla, nor does it boast the environmental benefits of a fully electric powertrain. Plus, with the plug-in hybrid model, the electric-only range is somewhat limited, and the gas engine can feel like a step backward after the electric motor.

Interior and Comfort

Tesla Model S

When you step inside the Tesla Model S, the first thing you’ll notice is the minimalist design. There’s hardly any clutter, and the 15-inch horizontal touchscreen controls nearly everything from navigation to climate control. The front seats are comfortable and supportive, but some might find the rear seats a bit tight for taller passengers.

Pros:

• Spacious and comfortable front seats
• Simple and clean interior
• High-quality materials
• Incredible amount of cargo space

Cons:

• Lack of physical buttons can be frustrating for some
• Rear seat comfort isn’t the best, especially for tall passengers

Some users have noted that the Model S lacks some of the high-end materials you'd expect in a car of this price range. It’s luxurious, yes, but not quite on the level of competitors like the BMW X5 in terms of cabin quality.

BMW X5

The BMW X5 offers a more traditional luxury SUV interior with a focus on high-quality materials and craftsmanship. It seats up to seven with the optional third row, although the third row can feel cramped for adults.

Pros:

• High-quality materials and a premium feel
• Spacious interior with a roomy backseat
• Comfortable for long journeys
• Optional third-row seating

Cons:

• Third-row seats can feel cramped
• Interior design, while premium, feels more traditional

"The X5 feels like you're in a high-end lounge with premium leather and wood accents—it's the type of car you don't mind spending hours in," adds Alex.

While the X5 delivers more traditional luxury, its tech interface isn’t quite as futuristic as the Tesla’s. The iDrive infotainment system works well, but it can feel a bit dated compared to Tesla’s intuitive touchscreen.

Technology and Infotainment

Tesla Model S

Tesla is known for pushing the boundaries of automotive tech, and the Model S is no exception. The centerpiece is the 15-inch touchscreen that controls almost everything. The Autopilot system offers semi-autonomous driving capabilities, with features like automatic lane changes and traffic-aware cruise control.

Pros:

• Incredible infotainment system with Netflix, YouTube, and even in-car gaming
• Over-the-air updates keep the car’s software fresh
• Autopilot is a standout feature

Cons:

• Autopilot isn’t fully autonomous yet, despite what some may think
• Some users find the screen-dominated interior distracting

The constant software updates ensure the Model S always feels up to date, but some drivers have reported bugs or issues after these updates, requiring troubleshooting that traditional cars simply don’t deal with.

BMW X5

The X5’s iDrive 7 system is one of the best in the business, even if it feels more traditional than Tesla’s touchscreen-based interface. It offers a 12.3-inch display, and there’s plenty of physical buttons and knobs, which some drivers prefer over relying solely on a screen.

Pros:

• Intuitive iDrive 7 system with physical controls
• Gesture controls add a bit of futuristic flair
• High-quality audio system from Harman Kardon

Cons:

• Not as flashy as Tesla’s tech, though it’s more reliable
• Over-the-air updates are not as frequent or significant

The X5 also includes several driver assistance features, like adaptive cruise control, lane-keeping assistance, and automated parking. However, it doesn’t offer the same level of semi-autonomous driving that Tesla does.

Safety

Tesla Model S

Tesla’s Model S has always been regarded as one of the safest cars on the road, and its NHTSA 5-star safety rating reinforces that reputation. It comes with a host of safety features, including forward collision warning, automatic emergency braking, and of course, Autopilot.

Pros:

• Excellent safety ratings
• Many safety features are standard
• Autopilot can help avoid collisions

Cons:

• Some concerns about over-reliance on Autopilot
• Minimal driver engagement in certain situations can be dangerous

BMW X5

The BMW X5 also boasts strong safety credentials, with plenty of advanced safety features like lane departure warning, blind-spot monitoring, and rear cross-traffic alert. Its active driving assistant package adds even more, including emergency braking and adaptive cruise control.

Pros:

• Advanced safety features come standard
• Great crash test results
• Excellent visibility for a large SUV

Cons:

• While packed with features, some are only available as options
• Larger vehicle can make parking or navigating tight spaces a bit tricky

Pricing

Tesla Model S

The Tesla Model S is undoubtedly a premium vehicle, with prices starting at around $88,000 and going up to over $130,000 for the Plaid version. There are no traditional trim levels, but buyers can choose between the standard Model S and the more expensive Plaid version.

"The Model S is worth it if you're looking for sheer electric performance and the best range in the game, but it's not cheap," Alex Collantes notes.

BMW X5

The BMW X5 has a wider price range, with the base model starting at $65,000. The plug-in hybrid version starts at around $73,000, and if you go for the high-performance X5 M model, you’re looking at close to $110,000.

Pros:

• More affordable base price compared to Tesla
• Wide range of options for different budgets

Cons:

• Options can get expensive quickly
• Fuel costs may be higher for traditional gas engines

Final Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?

Both the Tesla Model S and BMW X5 are incredible vehicles, but they cater to slightly different needs.

Tesla Model S:

• Best for: Tech enthusiasts, eco-conscious drivers, those who prioritize range and acceleration
• Not for: Traditionalists who prefer the sound and feel of a gas engine

BMW X5:

• Best for: Families or individuals needing more space, those who prefer traditional luxury and a wider variety of powertrain options
• Not for: Drivers who want cutting-edge technology or an all-electric vehicle

Ultimately, your decision comes down to what you prioritize in a vehicle. Whether you value the futuristic technology of the Model S or the luxurious comfort of the X5, both cars have a lot to offer.

What’s your pick? Feel free to share your thoughts in the comments!