2017 BMW X1 Steptronic vs. Sport: A Comprehensive Review of Two Exceptional Models

BMW has long been recognized for its luxury vehicles that combine performance, style, and technology, and the 2017 BMW X1 is no exception. However, with the availability of different trims and transmission options, deciding which model to buy can be tough. In this article, we’ll dive deep into a comparison between two popular variants: the 2017 BMW X1 Steptronic and the 2017 BMW X1 Sport. We’ll look at the pros, cons, and key features that differentiate these two models while keeping the language natural and professional for all readers.

Overview of the 2017 BMW X1 Steptronic

The BMW X1 Steptronic offers a combination of luxury and functionality with a smooth automatic transmission that appeals to those who prioritize comfort. The Steptronic transmission is BMW's proprietary automatic gearbox, offering a unique balance between fully automatic driving and manual control. The system enables drivers to switch gears manually when desired while enjoying the convenience of an automatic transmission most of the time.

• Engine Power: Powered by a 2.0-liter turbocharged inline-4 engine
• Transmission: 8-speed automatic with Steptronic
• Horsepower: 228 hp
• Torque: 258 lb-ft
• Fuel Economy: 22 mpg city / 31 mpg highway

Overview of the 2017 BMW X1 Sport

The 2017 BMW X1 Sport model focuses more on providing an engaging driving experience. With features tailored to deliver a sportier feel behind the wheel, this variant appeals to those who enjoy the thrill of driving. The X1 Sport comes with stiffer suspension tuning and more responsive handling than the Steptronic model.

• Engine Power: Same 2.0-liter turbocharged inline-4
• Transmission: 8-speed automatic (with sportier settings)
• Horsepower: 228 hp
• Torque: 258 lb-ft
• Fuel Economy: 22 mpg city / 31 mpg highway

Both models share the same engine, but the suspension, steering response, and transmission tuning are what set them apart.

Driving Experience: Steptronic vs. Sport

Steptronic Model

The Steptronic transmission is praised for its seamless shifts and versatility. The beauty of this system is its ability to adapt to different driving situations. You can enjoy a leisurely drive in full automatic mode, letting the transmission handle everything, or switch to manual mode to control the shifts yourself, all without the need for a clutch pedal.

"The Steptronic feels refined and is perfect for long highway drives or city cruising" says Alex Collantes, a long-time BMW enthusiast who has driven various X1 models over the years. "I love how you can switch to manual mode on twisty roads for a bit more engagement but it doesn’t give you that raw connection like a real manual."

Sport Model

On the other hand, the X1 Sport offers a slightly firmer and more aggressive driving experience. The suspension has been stiffened compared to the Steptronic model, making it more responsive in corners and giving the car a sportier feel.

However, it’s not without its trade-offs. While the Sport model is fun on the twisties, it can feel harsher on rough city streets or long trips. The steering in the Sport model is also tuned for a bit more feedback, which can be both a plus and a drawback depending on personal preference. Some drivers might find it more engaging, while others may think it’s too sensitive, especially during everyday driving.

Manual Mode vs. Sport Mode: What’s the Difference?

In terms of transmission, the Steptronic’s manual mode gives you control over gear shifts but doesn’t change the car’s character much. It’s great for taking over in situations where you need extra control, like overtaking or descending steep hills.

The Sport model on the other hand has an adaptive sport mode that changes the transmission’s behavior, holding gears longer, and adjusting throttle response for quicker acceleration. This makes it a more engaging drive for enthusiasts but can be a bit much for those who just want a comfortable ride.

Exterior Design

Steptronic Model

Visually, the Steptronic model leans towards a more traditional luxury SUV aesthetic. It doesn’t scream “performance” but maintains a sleek and classy design that appeals to a broader audience. The smooth lines and LED headlights give it an understated elegance that fits into any environment, whether it's parked in front of a high-end restaurant or on a suburban driveway.

Sport Model

The Sport model offers a more aggressive exterior styling with sportier bumpers, larger air intakes, and more prominent side skirts. The difference may not be massive at first glance, but upon closer inspection, these sporty elements add an extra layer of visual excitement. The 19-inch alloy wheels further complement the sporty nature of the vehicle.

Common Design Features

• Roof rails on both models for added utility
• Dual exhaust outlets for a balanced look
• Same wheelbase and overall dimensions

In terms of aesthetics, it really comes down to personal taste. The Steptronic offers a more reserved appearance, while the Sport model stands out a bit more.

Interior and Comfort

Steptronic Model

Inside, the Steptronic version provides luxury-focused features. The seats are upholstered in SensaTec synthetic leather, which is soft and durable. The overall layout of the interior is modern, with a focus on clean lines and user-friendly interfaces. The iDrive infotainment system is intuitive, and the cabin is well-insulated from road noise, making it a great vehicle for long trips.

Sport Model

The X1 Sport retains much of the same luxury, but with a few added touches to reflect its sportier identity. You get sports seats with added bolstering for better support during spirited driving. The steering wheel is thicker and has a sportier design. While these features are a plus for driving enthusiasts, some might find the firmer seats less comfortable for extended trips.

Shared Interior Features

• Panoramic sunroof standard on both models
• Dual-zone climate control
• 8.8-inch infotainment display with navigation
• Ample cargo space: 27.1 cubic feet behind the rear seats

Alex Collantes adds: "I’ve driven both models and honestly, it’s a toss-up. If you care about having a little more edge, the Sport’s seats feel better for spirited driving but for daily commutes the Steptronic's comfort wins."

Technology Features: How Do They Stack Up?

Both models of the 2017 BMW X1 come packed with technology features aimed at enhancing the driving experience.

Steptronic Model

The Steptronic leans more towards tech that makes driving easier. Lane departure warning and automatic emergency braking are included, along with an available head-up display that projects key information directly onto the windshield. There’s also Apple CarPlay integration and a suite of driver assistance features that help make driving as stress-free as possible.

Sport Model

While the X1 Sport includes many of the same tech features, its focus is slightly different. In addition to the driver assistance systems available on the Steptronic, the Sport model includes a sport display that shows information like power output and torque in real-time, catering to those who like to keep tabs on performance metrics while driving.

Notable Shared Features

• 360-degree camera for easier parking
• Available premium sound system
• Wireless charging for compatible devices

Pricing and Value

When it comes to pricing the 2017 BMW X1 Steptronic is generally a bit more affordable than the Sport model. The base price of the Steptronic starts around $35,000 while the Sport model tends to start closer to $37,000. The difference isn’t huge but may be a factor depending on your budget.

Potential Drawbacks:

• Steptronic: Some drivers might find it lacks the sporty feel they desire. It’s more suited to comfort than pure performance.
• Sport Model: The stiffer ride can be uncomfortable on rough roads or long trips. It’s more engaging but at the cost of daily driving comfort.

Pros and Cons: Steptronic vs. Sport

2017 BMW X1 Steptronic Pros:

• Smooth automatic transmission perfect for city and highway driving
• Comfortable ride even on long trips
• Slightly lower price point

2017 BMW X1 Steptronic Cons:

• Less sporty than some rivals in the compact luxury SUV segment
• Manual mode doesn’t feel as engaging as a true manual transmission

2017 BMW X1 Sport Pros:

• More engaging drive with firmer suspension and sportier tuning
• Sport seats offer better support in corners
• Adds an extra level of excitement without sacrificing practicality

2017 BMW X1 Sport Cons:

• Stiffer ride can become uncomfortable on rough roads
• Slightly higher starting price

Conclusion: Which One Should You Buy?

Choosing between the 2017 BMW X1 Steptronic and the X1 Sport ultimately comes down to what you value most in a vehicle. If comfort and versatility are at the top of your list, the Steptronic will likely be the better choice. Its smooth transmission and comfortable ride make it ideal for city driving and long trips alike.

However, if you want a more engaging and sport-oriented driving experience, the X1 Sport provides that without going overboard. You’ll feel more connected to the road, but be prepared to sacrifice some comfort in exchange for that added performance edge.

As Alex Collantes sums it up: “It’s hard to go wrong with either model but for someone who enjoys driving and doesn’t mind a firmer ride the Sport is the way to go. On the other hand if you’re looking for a luxury SUV that’s comfortable in all situations the Steptronic wins hands down.”

Regardless of which model you choose both variants of the 2017 BMW X1 provide the luxury, technology, and performance you’d expect from the BMW brand. The choice is yours and it’s hard to go wrong with either